The national press has picked up several reports in the Honolulu Star-Advertiser about the plight of Karen Okada.  Karen is a 95-year-old woman who signed a “Death with Dignity Declaration” and a “Durable Power of Attorney for Health-Care Instructions” back in 1998.  Both documents purport to control “in all circumstances.” Health-Care Directive

The Queen’s Medical Center, where Karen was hospitalized for pneumonia, determined that Karen was essentially brain dead, or, in any event, had “permanently” lost the ability to participate in medical treatment decisions, and that the provisions of her Death with Dignity Declaration required that her feeding tube be withdrawn.

On the other hand, Karen’s health-care agent, in consultation with doctors who are not associated with Queen’s, disagreed with the conclusions reached by the Queen’s physicians.  What the agent knew, and the Queen’s physicians discounted, was that just before she was hospitalized at Queen’s, Karen was conscious and able to interact meaningfully with her family and caregivers.  During the time she was at Queen’s, on the other hand, Karen was for the most part unresponsive when doctors examined her, but her family reported that she smiled at least twice at her adult grandchildren and nodded to her grandson in response to his question of whether she was able to breathe freely.

The policy of Queen’s was to give precedence to an advance health-care directive over a durable power of attorney in all events, and without inquiring into why a person may have signed apparently contradictory documents.  Accordingly, Queen’s took the unusual step of suing Karen’s health-care agent in order to get a court order forcing him to direct Karen’s physicians to remove her feeding tube.

Of course, no one would want to be part of this kind of drama.  So what can you do to make your wishes clearly known so there will be no questions about how to carry them out?

  1. If you do not have an advance-health care directive in place, get one.  Make sure your loved ones—including your children over the age of 18—have advance health-care directives too.
  2. Learn all you can about the options that can be written into your advance health-care directive.  These are not “one size fits all” documents.  Your wishes may differ greatly from those of your friends and family members, and the document you sign should express your particular desires.
  3. If you have an advance health-care directive that is more than 5 years old, there is a good chance that it will not accomplish what you think it will.  Review it right away with your legal counsel.  Make any appropriate changes and updates.
  4. If you want to give a trusted family member or friend the power to make health-care decisions for you, make sure the power of attorney meshes well with any other instructions you may want to provide.
  5. Be sure to give your health-care providers your permission to give your medical information to your family members or other trusted decision makers.  Federal and State privacy laws can restrict your doctor from talking with your health-care agent unless you specifically grant that permission.
  6. Review your advance health-care directive periodically to make sure it accurately states your current wishes.  Once per year is not too often.
  7. Make sure you have a mechanism in place for giving you access to your advance health-care directive, no matter when or where an emergency might occur.  Not all health problems happen in the home, and if you have a crisis situation while you are travelling, you will need a way to make your health-care documents accessible to your caregivers.
  8. Talk with your family about your wishes BEFORE a crisis arises.  Make sure everybody is on the same page.  If your chosen decision makers indicate hesitation about carrying out your wishes, think about naming someone who will.  Your assurance to your loved ones of how seriously you intend your instructions to be taken will give them the courage to carry them out.

Knowledge is power.  The more you know about advance health-care directives, and the sooner you act on that knowledge, the more likely it will be that your wishes will be carried out.

In case you were curious about what happened to Karen, her family was successful in gaining her release from Queen’s and placing her in a care home.  Since then, Karen has gained 20 pounds and has regained her ability to interact meaningfully with her family.

Scott A. Makuakane, Esq., CFP
Est8Planning Counsel LLLC
Honolulu, Hawaii

Providing Clear Direction in Your Advance Health-Care Directive was last modified: November 16th, 2022 by Scott Makuakane, Esq.